Is this translation request off-topic here?

3

This question Kiel traduki Esperante tiun ĉi ludkarton? requests a translation of the text of a playing card, not any specific word or phrase. Is it outside the topic for this site?

asked 2016-12-22T08:59:52.110

None

Answers

0

I understood the question to be "how do you translate the name of this monster" - which I chose not to answer but for other reasons. I do think it's essentially off topic and if our community is to have any value, we will come up with some guidelines about this.

asked 2016-12-22T08:59:52.110

None

0

I would consider it off-topic for the fact of asking how to translate in Esperanto a name of an imaginary creature. It is not a question that would help future users.

asked 2016-12-22T08:59:52.110

None